Maximize My Social Security and other products provided by Economic Security Planning, Inc. at www.esplanner.com and www.esplanner.com/basic are educational calculators designed to give you some input in mapping out your financial future, but should not be acted upon as a complete financial plan. Maximize My Social Security and its derivative products' creators are not certified, registered, authorized, or any other type of financial planners.
Maximize My Social Security and its derivative products are simply tools for helping you think through your economic futures. Their "suggestions" should be viewed as informative inputs into your own decision-making with respect to saving and the purchase of life insurance. Maximize My Social Security and its derivative products provide neither economic, financial nor tax advice, which can only be delivered to you by authorized professionals.
The Social Security benefit estimates produced by Maximize My Social Security are just that -- estimates. Only the Social Security Administration can tell you precisely the benefits to which you are or will be eligible and the amounts you will receive. The estimates provided here may differ from the correct amounts due to mistakes in our computer code of which we are unaware or because of legislated changes in Social Security provisions of which we are unaware or because of delays in our updating our computer code for changes in Social Security provisions.
Deciding When to Take Social Security Is Critically Important
No one can count on dying on time, i.e., at his/her current life expectancy. If you're married or partnered, the chances that both you and your spouse/partner will die on time are even smaller. Indeed, for 65 year-old married couples, theres a better than even chance that at least one member will live to his or her early nineties.
You need to plan to live to your maximum age of life, not your expected (average) age of life, for the simple reason that you might. For most of us, our maximum age of life is quite old. This tool takes 100 as its default value for the maximum age of life, but you can change this value under Assumptions.
Insuring against living as long as possible is no different than insuring against your house burning down. Most likely it won't happen. But if it does, you want to be insured. Having a high level of income that's protected against inflation and continues as long as you live is the way to insure yourself against excessive longevity.
Buying Longevity Insurance from Social Security
Social Security lets us, in effect, buy more of this longevity insurance by waiting to collect our benefits. The longer we wait (up to some limits discussed below), the higher will be our benefits once we start collecting. But the price we pay for waiting comes in the form of giving up benefits while we wait.
So how long should we wait to start collecting? Our tool helps you answer this question. As discussed below, the answer is different for different types of people who are eligible for different types of benefits.
And the right answer is not always to wait to take all benefits. Indeed, it may be optimal to take one type of benefit (e.g., a spousal benefit) earlier than another type of benefit (e.g., a retirement benefit).
Calculating the Present Value of Future Benefits
The tool shows you the present value (the value in the present) of the sum of all your future benefits based on the collections ages you select. But it also shows you the combination of collection ages for the different benefits that will provide the highest present value of benefits.
In forming the present value of all your future benefits for different collection date choices, we do simple discounting for real interest. That is, we don't engage in what's called actuarial discounting. Actuarial discounting takes into account the chances or probabilities of collecting particular benefits in particular future years. But such actuarial discounting, while appropriate for insurance companies, is not appropriate for individual households who can't count on dying at particular ages with the frequencies observed in large samples.
If your maximum age of life isn't very high, taking benefits earlier will likely produce the highest present value. The same is true if you set a higher interest rate under Assumptions. In forming the present value of your future benefits, our tool takes into account the real rate of return (the return after inflation) you can earn on your savings. If you set a higher interest rate, the program may recommend taking some of your benefits early because you are, in effect, telling the program that you can do better getting lower benefits starting right away and investing them yourself.
Cash Constraints and Future Benefit Cuts
There are two other reasons that it might be better to take benefits early. You may be cash constrained (also called liquidity or borrowing constrained) and need the Social Security income to live off right away. I.e., you may not have the luxury of waiting to collect. A second reason is that Social Security may reduce benefits in the future. The tool allows you to specify future benefit cuts, both when they will occur and their degree.
If you are cash-constrained, the present value of your benefits, while important, is not the only thing to consider. You will also want to compare the annual benefits you'll get if you collect immediately or at the earliest possible date and the higher benefits you can collect by waiting. In showing you these annual benefit amounts, this tool helps you decide if the immediate sacrifice is worth the long-term gain. The long-term gain can be substantial. Taking your full retirement benefits at age 70, rather than age 62, can result in a benefit that's more than 70 percent higher once you start collecting at 70.
Choosing When to Collect Particular Benefits -- Never Married, Divorced, and Widowed
This tool considers all of the OASI (Old Age Survivors Insurance) benefits to which you may be eligible, including retirement benefits, spousal benefits, survivor benefits, divorcee benefits, children benefits, and parent benefits. The tool does not include disability benefits. Social Security lets you choose, within some limits, when to start collecting your OASI benefits. The tool imposes these limitations.
If you are single and were never married, your choice is simple. You need to decide when to take your retirement benefit. You can collect starting at any time between age 62 and 70. If you start collecting before your full retirement age, your benefit will be reduced. If you wait to collect after your full retirement age, your benefit will be increased. After age 70, there is no further increase, known as the Delayed Retirement Credit, so there is no reason to delay benefit collection.
If you are single and divorced (after having been married for 10 years), you can elect to collect a spousal benefit based on your ex-spouse's work history once your ex reaches age 62. If you apply for your spousal benefit prior to your full retirement age and can collect it because your spouse is 62 or over, you will be deemed to be applying for early retirement benefits as well. And if you apply for early retirement benefits, you will be deemed to also be applying for your reduced spousal benefit as well if your ex is 62 or over. If you ex is under 62 at the time you apply for your reduced retirement benefit, you will be free to wait up to full retirement age to apply for your spousal benefit regardless of when your ex reaches age 62. Social Security reduces both retirement and spousal benefits based on separate retirement and spousal benefit reduction schedules.
Your total benefit as a divorcee will equal your retirement benefit, reduced, if you've taken it prior to full retirement age (or were deemed to be taking it), plus your excess spousal benefit, which will also be reduced if you are taking spousal benefits early (because you want to or are being deemed to be applying for them). Your excess spousal benefit is the difference between one half of your ex's full retirement benefit and your full retirement benefit IF you filed for or were forced (via deeming) to apply for your retirement benefit. Otherwise, the excess spousal benefit is simply equal to half of your ex's full retirement benefit. The full retirement benefit is called the Primary Insurance Amount (PIA). So the formula for the excess spousal benefit (before any reduction for taking spousal benefits early) is .5 x your ex's PIA less your PIA, except that if you have never filed for (or been forced via deeming to file for) your retirement benefit, Social Security views you as not having a PIA for purposes of computing the excess spousal benefit. As one of the chief actuaries put it, "Your PIA doesn't exist until you apply for it (your retirement benefit)."
If you are collecting your retirement benefit, then your PIA exists and the excess spousal benefit formula is .5 times your ex's PIA less your PIA. If this amount is negative, your excess spousal benefit is zero, so all you get is your own retirement benefit. If you are following all this, and we know it's not easy, what this means is that if you take your retirement benefit and your spousal benefit at the same time, your retirement benefit (your PIA, which would exist) may wipe out your spousal benefit.
To completely avoid wiping out or reducing your excess spousal benefit you need to not apply for either benefit until full retirement age and then apply only for your spousal benefit. Since you will never have applied for your retirement benefit, your PIA will not exist and the excess spousal benefit formula will equal simply half of your ex's PIA. If you wait until age 70 to collect your own retirement benefit, you'll receive half of your spouse's excess spousal benefit between full retirement age and age 70. And, by waiting until 70, you'll get the highest possible retirement benefit. If your retirement benefit, when you take it at, say, 70, wipes out your excess spousal benefit (makes it zero), you will have received "free" spousal benefits for several years without sacrificing getting the maximum possible retirement benefit.
Note that both you and your ex can play this game. You can both collect free spousal benefits on the other's work record. Married couples aren't able to do this. Only one can collect a free spousal benefit.
If you are single and widowed, you can take your survivor (also called widow's) benefit at any time between age 60 and your full retirement age. If you take your widow's benefit early, it will be reduced. Your widow's benefit will not be increased if you delay taking it past your full retirement age, so there is no reason to defer collecting it beyond that point.
If your former spouse was collecting reduced retirement benefits before he/she passed away and you take you survivor benefit early (before full retirement age), your survivor benefit will equal one of three calculated amounts -- your former spouse's reduced benefit amount, 82.5% of your former spouse's full retirement benefit (Primary Insurance Amount), or your former spouse's full retirement benefit reduced based on early survivor benefit reduction factor that applies to you.
If your deceased spouse doesn't take retirement benefits early and dies before reaching full retirement, your spousal benefit will equal 100 percent of your deceased spouse's full retirement benefit (his/her PIA). And if your deceased spouse waited beyond full retirement age to take retirement benefits your survivor benefit will equal his full retirement benefit augmented by the delayed retirement credit. I.e., you'll get the same check as he/she was receiving. And if your deceased spouse was over full retirement age when he/she passed away and had never collected his/her retirement benefit or had file for his/her retirement benefit and suspended its collection, your survivor benefit will equal your deceased spouse's PIA (full retirement benefit) augmented by the delayed retirement credits that he/she would have earned had he/she started receiving retirement benefits at his/her date of death.
Unlike spousal benefits, you can apply for your widow's benefit early without being deemed to be also applying for your retirement benefit. Hence, one strategy for widows is to start taking their survivor benefit at age 60 and defer until age 70 taking their retirement benefit. An alternative strategy is to take the retirement benefit early, e.g., at age 62, and to wait until full retirement to take the survivor benefit. This may make sense if the retirement benefit is smaller than the survivor benefit.
If your retirement benefit exceeds the survivor benefit and you have applied to collect both, you will receive only your retirement benefit. If your survivor benefit exceeds your retirement benefit, you will receive your retirement benefit and a redefined survivor benefit which is limited to the amount by which your survivor benefit exceeds your retirement benefit.
This is like the excess spousal benefit formula. What you receive as a survivor is really your own retirement benefit (potentially reduced if you took it early) plus an excess survivor benefit defined as your survivor benefit less your own retirement benefit, including any reduction for early retirement or any increment due to taking it after full retirement age. By taking your survivor benefit when you aren't taking your retirement benefit you can receive your full survivor benefit, rather than your excess survivor benefit. The only way to do this is to take your survivor benefit before you take your retirement benefit or are deemed to be taking your retirement benefit.
Choosing When to Collect Particular Benefits -- Married Couples
If you are married, you or your spouse, but not both, at least not simultaneously, can potentially collect a spousal benefit based on your partner's work history. If you apply for your retirement benefit early (before full retirement age) you will be deemed to be applying of your spousal benefit as well provided your spouse is either collecting his/her retirement benefit or has filed for his/her retirement and suspended its collection.
If you are married and apply for your spousal benefit early and are eligible to receive it because your spouse is either collecting a retirement benefit or has filed for his/her retirement benefit and suspended its collection, you will be deemed to be also applying for your retirement benefit early as well. In this case, both benefits will be subject to separate reduction factors.
The deeming provisions only apply at the time of initial application. Hence, if you apply for an early retirement benefit and want to wait to full retirement to take your spousal benefit, you can do so if, as mentioned above, your spouse is not collecting a retirement benefit at the time you apply for your retirement benefit. Furthermore, if your spouse starts collecting his/her retirement benefit before you reach full retirement age, you still won't be deemed to be applying for a spousal benefit. I.e., you are free to wait to retirement age to collect an unreduced spousal benefit.
Once you reach full retirement age, if you have not yet applied for a spousal benefit and your spouse is at or beyond full retirement age, you can apply for your unreduced spousal benefit and defer collecting your retirement benefit until age 70. To collect your spousal benefit, your partner must either be collecting his/her retirement benefit or have filed to collect his/her retirement benefit, but suspended its collection. By filing and suspending his/her retirement benefit collection, your partner can defer taking his retirement benefit until age 70 and receive a higher benefit when he/she does begin collecting thanks to the delayed retirement credit.
Since Social Security's benefit calculations preclude both spouses filing and suspending and both collecting spousal benefits on their partner's record, this tool asks you, if you are married, whether you or your spouse will file and suspend collection benefit collection at full retirement age or whether neither spouse will do so. The tool will find the collection dates for spousal and retirement benefits for each spouse conditional on the choice you entered with respect to filing and suspending. Hence, you should try both choices for which spouse files and suspends and see how the maximum present value of benefits compares in the two cases.
The ability to file and suspend and, thereby, let one spouse receive a "free" spousal benefit and let both spouses delay taking their retirement benefits and take advantage of the Delayed Retirement Credit can make a significant difference to the total present value of benefits received by the household.
The total benefit you'll collect as a spouse is your own retirement benefit plus your excess spousal benefit. Your excess spousal benefit is the difference between one half of your spouse's full retirement benefit and your full retirement benefit IF you filed for or were forced (via deeming) to apply for your retirement benefit. Otherwise, the excess spousal benefit is simply equal to half of your spouse's full retirement benefit. The full retirement benefit is called the Primary Insurance Amount (PIA). So the formula for the excess spousal benefit (before any reduction for taking spousal benefits early) is .5 x your spouse's PIA less your PIA, except that if you have never filed for (or been forced via deeming to file for) your retirement benefit, Social Security views you as not having a PIA for purposes of computing the excess spousal benefit. As one of the chief actuaries put it, "Your PIA doesn't exist until you apply for it (your retirement benefit)."
The bottom line here is that to get your largest possible spousal benefit, you need to wait until full retirement to apply for any benefit and at that point apply only for your spousal benefit.
Which Spouse Should File and Suspend?
Is it always best for the low earning spouse to be the one to collect spousal benefits and have the higher earning spouse always file and suspend? No, not if the higher earning spouse is younger. Then it may be better for the higher earning spouse to collect the free spousal benefits because he/she will be collecting for more years than would be the case if the other spouse went for the free spousal benefits. Again, you can quickly use the tool to see which option gives you the highest present value of benefits. Simply, run the tool twice, once with the husband filing and suspending and once with the wife filing and suspending.
Having both spouses wait to collect retirement benefits may not be optimal. It might be optimal for one spouse (say the wife) to collect retirement benefits early, say at 62, and then wait until full retirement to collect unreduced spousal benefits from that point forward. This is feasible when the other spouse (the husband) doesn't start collecting or file for and suspend his retirement benefit on or before the month that the wife files for her early retirement benefit. That is, when she is not eligible for spouse's benefits at the time she files for early retirement benefits.
Imposing the System's Restrictions on Benefit Collection Dates
This tool's interface will not let you specify spousal and retirement benefit collection ages independently when taking either one early.
File, Suspend, Reinstate Retirement Benefit Collection Strategies
This strategy is currently implemented in our software for those already receiving retirement benefits and will be implemented for those who have not yet filed in the next couple of months. Once you start collecting your retirement benefit you can suspend it provided you are at or beyond full retirement age. You can then reinstate your retirement benefit at a later date up through age 70 and received delayed retirement credits for each month during which your benefit has been suspended. No delayed retirement credits are provided for delaying your retirement benefit beyond age 70, so there is no reason to wait beyond 70 to reinstate your benefit.
If you do start and then suspend your retirement benefit and you are enrolled in Medicare Part B, you will be billed by the Center for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) for future Part B premiums. These premiums cannot be deducted from your suspended retirement benefits. If you do not pay the premiums timely, you may lose your Part B Medicare coverage. Exception: If you also receive benefits as a spouse or ex-spouse, Social Security can deduct your Part B premium from that benefit payment. MAKE SURE YOU SEND A CHECK EACH MONTH TO CMS FOR YOUR MEDICARE PART B PREMIUM IF YOU ARE ENROLLED IN MEDICARE PART B.
Why would using the retirement benefit File Suspend Reinstate strategy potentially be worth using? Well, consider a high earner, Sandy, who is 62 married to Daryl, who has reached full retirement age. If Sandy applies for her retirement benefit at 62, Daryl can immediately begin to collect a spousal benefit based on Sandy's earnings record. He can also postpone his own retirement benefit through age 70. When Sandy reaches full retirement age, she can suspend her benefit and wait until, say, 70, to collect a permanently higher benefit, namely the reduced benefit she was collecting augmented by the delayed retirement credits she earns during the months her benefit is suspended.
This might generate higher benefits in present value than, for example, having Sandy a) wait until full retirement to file and suspend for her retirement benefit at which point Daryl can start collecting a spousal benefit, while waiting until 70 to collect his retirement benefits, and then b) begin collecting her retirement benefit at 70.
Using ESPlanner to Understand the Living Standard Implications of Alternative Social Security Benefit Collection Dates
As indicated above, deciding when to take particular Social Security benefits is, as indicated above, a complicated decision. We hope this tool helps make this decision much easier. But this tool goes only so far. It does not show you your annual living standard under different choices of when to take particular benefits. Our download financial planning programs, ESPlanner, ESPlannerPLUS, and ESPlannerPRO (our only program licensed for professional use), which we market at www.esplanner.com, let you see what happens to your living standard each year based on your chosen collection dates. These programs take full account of the taxation of Social Security benefits by federal and state governments, which can also influence optimal benefit collection dates. Most important, the programs incorporate cash/borrowing constraints, showing users precisely what short-run living standard sacrifice might be needed in delaying taking benefits.
The download programs also let you consider different drawdown strategies with respect to your taxable retirement accounts (e.g., 401(k)s and regular IRAs) and your Roth IRAs and 401(k)s. By timing these withdrawals carefully, you may be able to reduce the taxation of your Social Security benefits. The reason is that withdrawals from taxable retirement accounts, but not withdrawals from Roth IRAs and Roth 401(k)s, are included as part of your Adjusted Gross Income for purposes of calculating taxes due on your Social Security benefits.
Comparing Our Benefit Calculations with Social Security's Benefit Statement
Social Security provides a quick retirement benefit estimator at www.ssa.gov. But this calculator does not take into account the spousal, divorcee, survivor, and child benefits to which you and your children may be eligible based on the work histories of your current or former spouse.
In addition, Social Security's quick retirement benefit estimator forms its benefit estimates assuming zero future economy-wide real wage growth and zero future inflation. Neither of these assumptions is realistic. Both differ from the assumptions made by the Social Security Trustees in their Annual Report. Social Security makes these assumptions to be conservative in telling people what they will be receiving. Our tool, in contrast, uses the Social Security Trustees' assumptions about future real wage growth and future inflation.
Social Security provides another, more detailed calculator, called AnyPIA, which lets you specify your own estimate of your future covered earnings as well as tell the tool to assume positive future real wage growth and inflation in forming its estimates.
But like its quick retirement benefit calculator, AnyPIA does not give you the ability to optimize over your own retirement benefit and benefits you can receive based on your current or former spouse's work history.
As you apply for those benefits, be sure to use your entitlement month, i.e. the month you start earning Social Security benefits, on your application. Maximize My Social Security recommendations are for benefit receipt months, i.e. the month that you receive your first check. Since Social Security pays benefits one month in arrears the receipt month is one month after the entitlement month. For example, if Maximize My Social Security recommends that you start receiving retirement benefits in Jan 2015, then you should apply with Social Security for entitlement starting in Dec 2014.
Also, be careful to start your entitlement neither too early nor too late. Social Security encourages you to apply 3 to 4 months before you want to start your entitlement. So in the above example, if you apply in Sep 2014, be sure to establish your entitlement month as Dec 2014.
The most important advice is to access the Social Security website and get their most current official guidance on how to apply.
Note that you can apply online, by phone, or in person, and that you should apply for benefits no more than four months before the date you want your benefits to start.